Recently we in contrast the 5-year-old Ryzen 5 1600 to the brand new Ryzen 5 5600 on an outdated B350 motherboard to see simply how a lot of an improve the Zen 3 processor is — and spoiler — it is a large improve that is properly value it for anybody who jumped on the AM4 platform early. A no brainer, with the 5600 now down to simply $175.
But what if in case you have the Ryzen 5 3600? This is the query many have requested us after seeing the above outcomes, so we went again to the take a look at bench to go for it. For people who missed the earlier evaluate, we have a 25 sport benchmark at 1080p and 1440p utilizing the Radeon RX 6950 XT and the extra mid-range 6600 XT, with SAM enabled.
The motherboard used for testing is the outdated MSI B350 Tomahawk utilizing the most recent BIOS revision based mostly on the AGESA 22.214.171.124 microcode, which permits Resizable BAR help together with help for Ryzen 5000 collection processors. Then we’ve got 32GB of DDR4-3200 CL14 dual-rank dual-channel reminiscence, and this similar configuration was used for testing all Ryzen processors.
With these particulars out of the way in which, let’s go over a couple of dozen of the video games examined after which we’ll check out the 25 sport common.
Starting with Fortnite we see that though the Ryzen 5 3600 is lots quick, the 5600 is way quicker, boosting efficiency with the 6950 XT at 1080p by a whopping 56% at 1080p.
Even with the 6600 XT, the R5 5600 was 47% quicker than the 3600 at 1080p, although that margin was diminished to 16% at 1440p. Still, for Fortnite gamers it seems like Zen 2 is quick sufficient, pushing body charges properly over 250 fps on common with 1% lows of over 160 fps.
Next up we’ve got Assetto Corsa Competizione and right here the 3600 performs rather well, boosting common body fee efficiency over the unique 1600 by as much as 52%. Moreover, it was simply 15% slower than the 5600 when paired with the 6950 XT at 1080p.
Big features for Zen 2 over Zen right here, whereas Zen 3 was as much as 18% quicker which admittedly remains to be an affordable efficiency benefit, however won’t warrant the $175 funding within the 5600.
The Ryzen 3600 carried out even higher in Cyberpunk 2077 relative to the 5600, sometimes trailing by a 7% margin. That means it was considerably quicker than the 1600 when extra CPU-limited with the 6950 XT. Another spectacular outcome that should not see 3600 homeowners in want of a 5600 improve.
As we have discovered beforehand Dying Light 2 is not a heavy CPU person and because of this even the Ryzen 5 1600 does properly right here. That mentioned, the 3600 was higher when paired with high-end GPUs because it was capable of match the 5600 at each 1440p and 1080p utilizing the 6950 XT.
Moving on, we’ve got F1 2021 and it is a sport that regardless of operating at a lot decrease body charges with the Ryzen 5 1600, it was very playable with properly over 100 fps always. That being the case, 3600 homeowners who predominantly play F1 2021 will not really feel the necessity to improve given efficiency right here has been boosted by as much as 37% over the 1600. The proven fact that it is nonetheless 32% slower than the 5600 is of no consequence given we’re speaking about common body charges in extra of 200 fps.
The Far Cry 6 outcomes are fascinating as they turn out to be GPU sure rapidly utilizing the prime quality preset, but there is no efficiency distinction between the 3600 and 5600, which is odd, however the efficiency of Far Cry video games has at all times been a bit unusual and do not make the most of CPUs very properly. But when in comparison with the 1600, the Ryzen 3600 is as much as 57% quicker, which is a large enchancment.
The Forza Horizon 5 outcomes are extra typical. Using the 6950 XT at 1080p, the 3600 was 46% quicker than the 1600 and 16% slower than the 5600. That margin is diminished to simply 11% at 1440p and though that also makes the 5600 an excellent bit quicker, the 3600 remains to be averaging over 200 fps which is lots quick.
Then with the 6600 XT, the Ryzen 3600 and 5600 are evenly matched as a result of GPU limitation, although at 1080p the 3600 was 26% quicker than the 1600. For these eager to push over 144 fps, the 3600 is greater than able to that in Forza.
Moving on to Hitman 3, we discover that the Ryzen 3600 is ready to match the 5600 for essentially the most half, except the 1080p information with the 6950 XT the place it was 13% quicker. For most taking part in Hitman 3 the efficiency distinction between the 3600 and 5600 will probably be minimal, however from the 1600 to the 3600, properly, that is an enormous improve netting gamers as much as 53% extra efficiency.
The Riftbreaker was a sport that actually broke the Ryzen 5 1600, resulting in stuttery gameplay that wasn’t in any respect fulfilling. The Ryzen 5 3600 is a giant step up with far fewer body pacing points however the as much as 36% higher 1% low efficiency you may obtain from the 5600 was noticeable. The Zen 3 half delivered completely clean efficiency so that is an instance the place the improve from the 3600 to the 5600 could be value it.
Next we’ve got Rainbow Six Extraction and right here the Ryzen 5 1600 had no problem offering clean playable efficiency, with not less than 170 fps on common when paired with a high-end GPU. Needless to say, the 3600 was positive, usually matching the 5600 with the largest margin seen at 1080p with the 6950 XT the place the Zen 2 half was 8% slower.
The final sport we will take a look at the person outcomes for is Watch Dogs Legion. This is a CPU demanding sport that tended to overwhelm the Ryzen 5 1600. The Ryzen 3600 had no problem although, maintaining body charges above 60 fps when efficiency was CPU restricted and was by no means greater than 12% slower than the 5600.
25 Game Average
Using a high-end GPU such because the Radeon 6950 XT at a low 1080p decision, the Ryzen 5 3600 was on common 43% quicker than the first-gen 1600, which is an enormous efficiency uplift.
The 5600 was solely 19% quicker than the 3600 although, and whereas that may be a notable enchancment, we frequently discovered little to no distinction between the 2 in gaming duties as even on this state of affairs some titles have been GPU restricted utilizing dialed down high quality settings.
We’re certain lots of you could possibly simply justify a CPU improve for ~19% extra efficiency on common, given for years a number of new CPU generations result in perhaps a 5% efficiency improve.
Now, for these gaming with a slower GPU, one thing alongside the strains of the mid-range Radeon 6600 XT, the Ryzen 3600 was on common 23% quicker than the 1600 at 1080p, whereas the 5600 was 14% quicker than the 3600. At 1440p we’re taking a look at single-digit margins as efficiency was usually closely GPU restricted.
Here’s a take a look at the 1% low margins seen throughout all 25 video games when evaluating the 5600 to the 3600 with the 6950 XT at 1080p. On common the Ryzen 5600 was simply 17% quicker, although we did discover 7 cases the place the margin exceeded 20%, with features as excessive as 59%, seen in Fortnite.
Primarily, for these taking part in aggressive multiplayer video games the improve to the 5600 from the 3600 will most likely be value it. But if you happen to’re taking part in single participant titles corresponding to Far Cry 6 and Dying Light 2 to quote two examples, it will make sense to stay with the 3600.
Using the 6600 XT at 1080p, we discover that the margins for the 1% lows are diminished additional and now the 5600 was on common simply 12% quicker. Titles corresponding to Fortnite utilizing aggressive high quality settings will nonetheless tremendously profit from the quicker CPU, however round half of the video games examined noticed little to no efficiency enchancment.
Zen 2 vs. Zen 3 Gaming: Upgrade or Not?
It’s fairly clear that anybody operating a Zen or Zen+ processor on an outdated 300 collection motherboard ought to look into snagging a brand new inexpensive Ryzen 5 5600 or Ryzen 7 5700X processor. No actual surprises right here based mostly on what we have seen from earlier testing, however it was nonetheless cool to match the brand new Ryzen 5 5600 on an outdated B350 motherboard with the R5 1600 and 3600.
For Zen 2 homeowners operating one thing just like the Ryzen 5 3600, it is much less apparent what you need to do although, and in lots of cases the improve for the 5600 is not value it. But once more, that can rely upon the video games you are taking part in and the way you play them, in order that will probably be so that you can work out.
Assuming your video games are sometimes closely CPU restricted, then the improve to the 5600 will ship large efficiency features, and if you happen to’re seeking to increase efficiency outdoors of simply gaming then the Ryzen 7 5700X for simply $300 is an effective way of doing that.
Otherwise for really large gaming efficiency features you would be trying extra on the 5800X3D and on the time of constructing this video it’s obtainable on the $450 MSRP, however that is a critical funding, particularly for these utilizing older motherboards. Granted, it does work properly as we have already proven and examined, however when speaking about bigger investments we really feel it could even be value ready for AM5 to reach and assess your choices then.